Your First Mistake as a New Nurse Leader? Trying to Fix Everything

Sisterly Advice™ Leadership Series · Season 2 · Helen Loflin

November 2026 · Estimated read time: 6–7 minutes · Leadership Development

You worked hard to become a nurse leader. But what if trying to fix everything right away is making your job harder?

The Pressure to Prove Yourself

You see problems that need attention. Processes that could work better. Team members looking to you for answers. And perhaps you feel that the sooner you start making changes, the sooner others will recognize your ability to lead.

That pressure is understandable. But what if trying to fix everything is actually making your job harder?

In this article, we'll explore a different approach to leadership: one that prioritizes understanding before action. Drawing from our conversation with Helen Loflin on the Sisterly Advice™ Podcast, we'll examine how observation, trust, and consistency can help leaders make meaningful improvements without creating unnecessary resistance.

You'll walk away with five practical strategies to build credibility, engage your team, and lead with greater confidence—whether you're a new charge nurse, nurse manager, or experienced leader entering a new environment.

When Our Strengths Become Our Challenges

Nurses are trained to recognize problems and respond. We assess situations, identify priorities, anticipate complications, and intervene. These abilities are essential to safe patient care.

But leadership introduces a different challenge. When we move from bedside nursing into leadership, we often bring that same urgency to every situation.

A communication breakdown? Fix it. A process that isn't working? Change it. A team struggling with accountability? Create a new expectation.

The challenge is that operational problems are rarely as straightforward as they initially appear. Behind every process are people, experiences, constraints, and sometimes years of adjustments made in response to problems that may no longer be visible.

What appears inefficient to a new leader may be a workaround the team developed to protect patient care. Before we can improve something, we need to understand why it exists. And understanding requires something that can feel uncomfortable when everyone expects you to lead: time to observe.

A Lesson From Helen Loflin: You Don't Have to Fix Everything on Day One

During our conversation on the Sisterly Advice™ Podcast, Helen Loflin shared her experience stepping into an interim executive leadership role at a hospital where she had never worked before.

She entered an unfamiliar environment with significant responsibilities and an understandable desire to make a difference. But instead of immediately introducing changes, she intentionally held herself back.

“I had to strain myself not to jump into the to-do list of things I thought needed to be corrected. It's not what I think. I honestly had to hold myself back.” — Helen Loflin

For approximately two months, Helen focused on observing, listening, connecting with team members, and understanding how the organization functioned. When opportunities for improvement emerged, they were informed by the people doing the work.

A leader can introduce a change and obtain compliance. But when team members participate in identifying problems and developing solutions, they have a greater opportunity to understand the purpose of the change and take ownership of the results.

Leadership is not about arriving with every answer. It is about creating the conditions where the right answers can emerge.

1. Observe Before You Change

Think about the first few weeks of a new leadership role. You are learning names, understanding expectations, reviewing quality indicators, and becoming familiar with the team. At the same time, you may feel pressure to demonstrate progress.

But observation is not inactivity. It is an essential part of understanding the environment you are responsible for supporting.

William Bridges (2009), in his work on organizational transitions, explains that transitions involve a period of uncertainty as individuals adapt to new responsibilities and identities. For nurses entering leadership, that uncertainty can create a desire to act quickly.

Instead, consider asking:

  • What is working well on this unit?
  • What challenges do team members experience repeatedly?
  • Which processes create unnecessary work?
  • What changes have already been attempted?
  • What do team members believe would make their work easier or safer?

These conversations help us identify problems that are not immediately visible in performance reports.

Put it into practice: During your first weeks in a leadership role, schedule dedicated time for observation and conversations with frontline staff. Keep a record of recurring concerns, strengths, and opportunities. Important safety concerns should always be addressed promptly; observation must never delay necessary action.

2. Build Relationships Before Expecting Trust

When we become leaders, we receive responsibility and authority. But trust is something different. Trust develops through our interactions, our willingness to listen, and our consistency in following through.

Helen's approach to entering an unfamiliar hospital reflected this distinction. Rather than relying on her position, she spent time learning about the people and building relationships.

For a new charge nurse or nurse manager, this may begin with simple interactions. Ask a team member what makes their day more difficult. Listen without immediately offering a solution. Follow up on a concern someone shared. Recognize the knowledge and experience already present on the team.

Amy Edmondson (2019) describes psychological safety as an environment where people feel able to speak up, ask questions, and acknowledge mistakes without fear of interpersonal punishment. Leaders contribute to that environment through their everyday responses.

When someone raises a concern, do we become defensive? When we don't know an answer, are we comfortable admitting it? When team members offer a different perspective, do we genuinely consider it?

Put it into practice: In your next leadership conversation, ask one question and focus on understanding the answer before proposing a solution. Sometimes listening is the most productive action we can take.

3. Remember That You Don't Have to Solve Everything Alone

Another valuable lesson from Helen's interview was the perspective she gained from working across a healthcare system. She realized that many challenges experienced at one hospital were also occurring at others. Some organizations were still working through those challenges; others had already developed effective approaches.

Instead of developing every solution independently, she recognized the value of connecting with colleagues, learning from their experiences, and adapting what worked.

You may be the charge nurse responsible for coordinating a difficult day. You may be a new manager trying to address staffing challenges, improve communication, or strengthen team engagement. You don't have to have every answer.

Reach out to experienced colleagues. Learn from other units. Ask what has worked and what hasn't. Peter Senge (1990) emphasized the importance of organizational learning and developing shared knowledge.

Put it into practice: Identify one challenge on your unit and connect with a colleague who has addressed something similar. Compare approaches before developing an entirely new process.

4. Don't Confuse Slow Results With Lack of Progress

One of the most meaningful parts of our conversation with Helen involved maintaining consistency when performance metrics had not yet reflected the team's improvement efforts.

She recognized that the work was moving in the right direction, even though the final outcomes would take longer to become visible. Earlier in her career, she might have responded by pushing harder or introducing additional changes. Instead, she focused on reinforcing the behaviors that were producing improvement.

In healthcare, we monitor falls, hospital-acquired infections, patient experience, turnover, and many other performance indicators. These measures help us identify risk, evaluate outcomes, and understand where improvements are needed.

But not every fluctuation requires a new intervention. Sometimes we must determine whether processes are working consistently and whether enough time has passed to evaluate their effect.

W. Edwards Deming (1986) emphasized understanding variation and avoiding unnecessary reactions to performance fluctuations.

“What we know brings us results is consistency. And consistency means the same aligned behaviors over a period of time. That is what gets us to an ultimate goal.” — Laura Wilkinson

Consistency requires discipline. It also requires communicating progress to the team, recognizing their efforts, and showing how daily work contributes to better outcomes.

Put it into practice: Alongside outcome metrics, review the behaviors and processes your team can influence each day. Discuss progress, identify barriers, and recognize improvements. Consistency does not mean ignoring problems; it means understanding when to adjust and when to allow an effective process to produce results.

5. Give Yourself Permission Not to Know Everything

New leadership roles can be uncomfortable. You may have years of clinical experience and still encounter situations where you don't know the answer. You might be unfamiliar with a process, a reporting system, or an organizational expectation. That does not mean you are incapable of leading.

During the podcast, Helen discussed the importance of remaining open to learning, even at the executive level. Leadership growth requires humility. The willingness to acknowledge what we don't know creates opportunities for collaboration.

For charge nurses, this may mean asking an experienced colleague for guidance. For managers, it may mean involving frontline staff in redesigning a process. For executives, it may mean recognizing that the people closest to the work often see challenges that are not apparent from a conference room.

Put it into practice: Replace the pressure to provide an immediate answer with a commitment to finding the right one. Saying, “I don't know yet, but let's work through it together,” can begin a productive conversation.

Five Questions to Ask Before Making Your Next Change

  1. Do I fully understand the problem, or am I reacting to what I see?
  2. Have I listened to the people affected by this decision?
  3. Do I understand why the current process exists?
  4. Have I explored solutions already working elsewhere?
  5. How will I know whether the change is effective, and how will I support consistency?

These questions won't eliminate every leadership challenge. But they can help us make thoughtful decisions and involve our teams in improvement.

Leadership Is Not Measured by How Quickly You Change Things

What I appreciated most about Helen's experience was her willingness to share how her approach to leadership has evolved. Experience taught her that she didn't need to respond to every challenge with an immediate solution. She could observe, listen, learn, and work with her team.

You do not have to prove your value by fixing everything. You demonstrate leadership by understanding what matters, supporting the people around you, making informed decisions, and following through.

Before you change the process, understand the people. Before you introduce the solution, understand the problem.

Leadership Reflection

Think about a time when you felt pressure to make an immediate change.

What might have been different if you had spent more time observing and listening?

If you're stepping into a new role today, what is one thing you can learn from your team before deciding what needs to change?

Sisterly Advice™

Understand First. Lead Better.

Good leadership is not measured by how quickly you make changes. It is reflected in how well you understand the problem, involve the people doing the work, and follow through.

Your reflection: What can you learn from your team before your next decision?

The Bottom Line

Helen Loflin's experience reminds us that meaningful leadership requires patience, curiosity, and consistency. The strongest leaders don't assume they have every answer. They take time to understand their teams, learn what is working, and create improvements with the people they lead.

Slow down. Learn first. Lead better.

Continue the Conversation

This article was inspired by our conversation with Helen Loflin on Season 2 of the Sisterly Advice™ Podcast, where we explore trust, professional growth, and the experiences that shape us as nurse leaders.

Explore Sisterly Advice™

References

  1. Bridges, W. (2009). Managing transitions: Making the most of change (3rd ed.). Da Capo Press.
  2. Deming, W. E. (1986). Out of the crisis. MIT Press.
  3. Edmondson, A. C. (2019). The fearless organization: Creating psychological safety in the workplace for learning, innovation, and growth. Wiley.
  4. Senge, P. M. (1990). The fifth discipline: The art and practice of the learning organization. Doubleday.
Next
Next

Leadership Has Nothing to Do With Your Title: Lessons From Helen Loflin on Influence, Trust, and Showing Up Without Authority